If It's Too Loud...
For my two cents, the rockin'-est part of Rock Band is easily the drums. Problem is, I haven't been able to play them much lately. My game time comes after 10 p.m. when my wife and kids are asleep, and whacking the crap out of fake drums kinda tends to make one hell of a racket. Such offenses do not go unpunished, so my project this weekend was to try to muffle the damn things.

The first attempt was downright feeble — rubberbanding some washcloths over the top. That just failed — the drum sticks whacked them right off. After that and some sage advice from Dan, I got more creative. I picked up four cheap mouse pads, cut them into drum-sized circles, and used velcro tape to stick them on top. That worked great for the muffling, but my scores immediately plummeted from 95% or higher to a pathetic 85%. Clearly, the mouse-pad mufflers interfered too much with the drum controller's ability to "receive," for lack of a better word. So I'm stumped, but I'm sure I'm hardly the only ones with this problem. You have any ideas or solutions? Post them into the comments below, and if anything comes out of it, we'll make it into a full-blown story and give you credit and lavish gifts. And yes, by "lavish," I mean an OXM T-shirt, , but I am serious about giving credit where it's due and seeing if we can tap the group OXM mind to solve this one...
UPDATE — SOLUTIONS
Good stuff, thanks everyone. I think what was wrong with my mouse-pad attempt was using velcro tape, which likely created too much of a gap between the pad and the drum, and messed up the responsiveness. Sorthing through the comments below, here's a summary of what seems like the best approach:
How to create effective muffling pads for the drums
Good option for quieter drum sticks
Thanks again, hope this helps everyone, and if you have more ideas, keep 'em coming!
![]()
instantdeath999
February 18, 2008 at 10:40pm
I have yet to test it, but my friend say's he simply puts a blanket over them. I'll try it tommorow.
![]()
ethanjude
December 03, 2007 at 11:47am
Not much. You can go to the local Guitar Center or music store and get them for $15 or less.
![]()
ethanjude
November 29, 2007 at 11:20am
Go to your local music store and ask for a pair of plastic brush drumsticks. I am in the same boat, wife and 3 kids and I play when they are asleep. The brushes wil allow you to play without really compromising the equipment.
http://www.guitarcenter.com/Regal-Tip-Ed-Thigpen-Plastic-Brushes-490357-...
These are a pretty good option.
![]()
free420
November 29, 2007 at 8:39am
Here's a forum thread on the topic via Joystiq: http://www.quartertothree.com/game-talk/showthread.php?t=40248&page=2 Looks like some thin, circular mouse pads from Staples might be an option. From the thread: "Just got back from Staples. These $2.98 Staples round mouse pads (Item 502501) look ideal! They are 8 1/2" diameter, 1/8" thick. Very thin fabic layer over neoprene...Conclusion? EXTREMELY EFFECTIVE! The thin round neoprene mousepads are far more effective than anything I've done with the stick tips. This one change probably muted the sound by 60% or more. It is a dramatic and unarguable noise reduction. You can actually hear the goddamn music now, and not a mind-numbing, repetitive, sometimes erratic tok tok tok a tok tok. OMG so much better."
![]()
Juggler_of_Geese
November 29, 2007 at 7:31am
I saw on Twitter that Will Smith purchased a pair of Quiet Drumsticks. You should ask him where he got them. He still works for Future doesn't he.
![]()
Bennanias
November 28, 2007 at 6:45pm
do what real drummers do when they are too loud, put up a fiberglass wall. no way to really stop sound, only dampen it. you can go with eggshell padding to try to absorb and disperse the sound, but i think the family wound preffer wood clacking than walls covered with foam. the problem with padding is while it dampens the sound, it makes less contact with the "drums". so i guess the right solution is finding the most amount of padding while still being able to make contact. sheets of cloth maybe. you could always go to a real music store and see what they say. if you were the modding type, i would say open up the drums and make them more sensitive while keeping the original idea.
![]()
free420
November 28, 2007 at 6:38pm
This idea was posted on Kotaku today: "By applying one layer of self-adhesive rubber and another of self-adhesive, colored felt, they claim to maintain full responsiveness while cutting down on the kit sound by 70%" Seems like a valid solution. There's a video at the end demonstrating the difference. Hope it works for you. http://generationgamerz.com/v2/insight/time-for-rock-band-arts-crafts.php
![]()
dartvader1171
November 28, 2007 at 5:50pm
Well, I guess that the most likely thing is you might want to try to contain the sound and just stop the noise from escaping the room because cushioning the pad ,or even stick for that matter, will disrupt the drum stick and pad connection. you ever lived in a soundproofed bubble before? " And then god said, 'let there be rock', and there was rock." May Rock band forever live.















